Kelley Wentworth went from a forgettable early boot in San Juan del Sur to one of Survivor's all-time idol artists. In Second Chance, marooned on the wrong side of the numbers, she sat on an idol for weeks — then played it as the dominant alliance dumped nine votes on her, erasing every single one and sending Andrew Savage to the jury. It remains the largest idol negation in history.
She found and played two idols that season and very nearly ran the table, falling in fourth. A third try on Edge of Extinction added another idol play before another blindside. Few players have ever made the hidden immunity idol look like a personal specialty the way she did.
