Josh Canfield was the quiet mastermind of early San Juan del Sur — a Broadway singer and actor who controlled Coyopa's first three votes while keeping his hands clean. He and Reed Kelly had applied separately, and producers didn't know the two were a couple until the game began.
Switched to a winning tribe, Josh coasted on immunity wins into the merge — then was blindsided in eleventh when his ally Baylor Wilson defected to Jeremy Collins. A sharp social-strategic player undone at the worst moment.
