Nadiya Anderson came to San Juan del Sur a known quantity — half of The Amazing Race's 'Twinnies' with her sister Natalie, a CrossFit coach with a reputation for being a threat. That pedigree painted a target on her from minute one.
Her tribe took the chance to remove a strong, savvy player early, and Nadiya was the first person voted out of the season. Her exit lit the fuse for Natalie's revenge-fueled run to the title.












