Castaway
John Carroll
The mastermind of Marquesas's dominant Rotu alliance, whose overconfidence galvanized the others to flip and cut him at nine.
John Carroll was the mastermind of Marquesas's Rotu alliance — the registered nurse who built and ran the bloc that controlled the early merge. His undoing was hubris: his crew's open, smug 'pecking order' at challenges convinced the other five to band together.
Once they flipped, John was the first big target, voted out ninth in the move that turned the whole season upside down.
Pulled from the urn — every vote ever cast against John, and how often John read the night right.
Add Johnto your ranking, then drag them into your 1→N order.
Rank John
Add Johnto your ranking, then drag them into your 1→N order on the rank page.
want to make the case? score the six skills
The facts are settled; the read is yours — your deep take on John. Two layers, never blended into one mystery number. (Separate from your ranking.)
Pulled straight from the dataset. Ungameable — nobody scores these, they just are.
Under Fire · auto-computed
8 votes against
across 3 Tribal Councils — the heat their game drew
What the data can’t measure. Score every skill, cite a moment.
Overall is a plain average of every skill you scored — no hidden math. It’s your deep read on John; your ranking is a separate ordered list.
Saving to this browser.to keep your scorecards and publish them.
Castaways John shared the island with — tap any face to cross over to their game.
Around the fire
Cast your vote, drop a hot take, and climb your torch — every contribution is tied to your profile at Tribal Council.
Join the debate at Tribal
