All castaways
Maddy Pomilla

Castaway

Maddy Pomilla

Maddy Pomilla

A charity projects manager who became the first person voted out of Survivor 44 when Brandon Cottom played an idol and used his lone vote against her.

Seasons
1
Occupation
Charity projects manager
Hometown
Brooklyn, NY
The story

Maddy Pomilla came to Survivor 44 a charity projects manager playing for 'girl power' and a short-term plan. She never got the runway.

In one of the wildest opening Tribals in years, Brandon Cottom played a hidden idol and used his lone remaining vote to make Maddy the first person voted out of the season, finishing seventeenth.

By the torchlight

Career record

17th
best finish
3
days on the island

Where they finished

the bigger the blaze, the deeper the run

  1. 17thS44
  1. 44

    Survivor 44

    17th

    2023 · Mamanuca Islands, Fiji · Ratu

    3 days

Read the votes

At Tribal Council

Pulled from the urn — every vote ever cast against Maddy, and how often Maddy read the night right.

1
vote against
1
Tribal sat at
Where they rank

Where does Maddy rank?

Add Maddyto your ranking, then drag them into your 1→N order.

Rank Maddy

Add Maddyto your ranking, then drag them into your 1→N order on the rank page.

want to make the case? score the six skills

The scorecard

Score Maddy’s game

The facts are settled; the read is yours — your deep take on Maddy. Two layers, never blended into one mystery number. (Separate from your ranking.)

The Record — the facts

📜 from the data

Pulled straight from the dataset. Ungameable — nobody scores these, they just are.

17th
Best finish
S44
1
Season
3
Days lasted

Under Fire · auto-computed

1 vote against

across 1 Tribal Council — the heat their game drew

The Read — your rating

What the data can’t measure. Score every skill, cite a moment.

5.0
overall
5
5
5
5
5
for fun5

Overall is a plain average of every skill you scored — no hidden math. It’s your deep read on Maddy; your ranking is a separate ordered list.

Saving to this browser.to keep your scorecards and publish them.

Just for fun: Maddy or…?A quick gut-check game — tap the better player. Doesn’t touch your ranking.
The wider tribe

Played alongside Maddy

Castaways Maddy shared the island with — tap any face to cross over to their game.

44Survivor 442023+5 more from Survivor 44
Around the fire

Common questions

Did Maddy Pomilla win Survivor?
No. Maddy Pomilla competed on Survivor but did not win. A charity projects manager who became the first person voted out of Survivor 44 when Brandon Cottom played an idol and used his lone vote against her.
How many times has Maddy Pomilla played Survivor?
Maddy Pomilla has played 1 season of Survivor: Season 44 (Survivor 44).
What is Maddy Pomilla's best finish on Survivor?
Maddy Pomilla's best finish is 17th on Survivor: Survivor 44 (Season 44).
How many days has Maddy Pomilla played Survivor?
Maddy Pomilla has spent 3 days on the island across 1 season.
How many times was Maddy Pomilla voted against at Tribal Council?
Across 1 Tribal Council, 1 vote was cast against Maddy Pomilla.
What is Maddy Pomilla known for?
A charity projects manager who became the first person voted out of Survivor 44 when Brandon Cottom played an idol and used his lone vote against her.

Around the fire

The tribe's debating Maddy's game right now

Cast your vote, drop a hot take, and climb your torch — every contribution is tied to your profile at Tribal Council.

Join the debate at Tribal